Natalie Mayer, judge: 'Beautiful dramatic light and a fun image. It is a shame some facial expression can't be seen' Photograph: Chris Mole
Natalie Mayer, judge: 'A lovely moment captured here. The image would have benefitted from a lower viewpoint to create the effect that we are looking at things more from the mens' perspective. This standing eye level perspective makes me very conscious of the "photographer" and thus lessens the spontaneity of the image' Photograph: Karina Klucnika
Natalie Mayer, judge: 'This is a very genuine moment captured, and I like the photographer's comment on the shot. The image could benefit from a more in-depth look at black and white conversions - sometimes the automatic conversions that come with consumer software, or in camera, are very basic and leave the image flat. A bit more contrast would add interest to the image'
Photograph: Annabelle Butterworth Photograph: Action images