Photograph: Hugo Wallis Photograph: Action images
Photograph: Laurens Meulman Photograph: Action images
Natalie Mayer, judge: This image has real potential, although doesn't quite hit the mark. The photographer would have benefited from waiting for a real "moment'" rather than just shooting into the scrum. Still, I've chosen it as a runner-up because I like the fact the photographer appears to have got properly close to the action and is photographing something which is culturally interesting, which is important in travel photography. Squeezing himself round to the front to get some of the expressions would have helped, as would including something that would have given us a clue as to what all these fellas are actually up to. Photograph: Luke Casey
Natalie Mayer, judge: This is a pleasing image with good composition, nicely exposed and post-processed. It's a bit of a tired scene though – I've seen countless images of this kind ... lonely tree, desolate landscape, moody sky. Still, replicating great shots in a technically proficient way is great training: the photographer should just be sure to search for more original scenes as he moves forward. Photograph: James Drury
Natalie Mayer, judge: Technically great; I'm guessing this must be a HDR image. However, imagine the image with a little extra something ... a cat crossing the road, a person lurking between shadow and light, somebody causing a ripple in the puddles ... something of that nature would set the image apart from a being a technical challenge well executed to a great image worthy of a win.
Photograph: Paul Cook Photograph: Action images
Natalie Mayer, judge: Lovely composition and moment. I find the ladies head/eyes at the top distracting – it takes away from the boy. Also, it would be nice to have a bit more of a feel for what is going on and why his hands are in the air, but still, a lovely image.
Photograph: Angus MacRae Photograph: Action images
Natalie Mayer, judge: This image has great presence, it really stood out to me. It would be nice to see a bit more shape to get a glimpse of what the girls are actually up to, but despite this, it's a very striking image and the flying hair invokes a good atmosphere and feeling of the moment. Photograph: Slawek Kozdras
Natalie Mayer, judge: There were lots of commendable entries this month but this one really stood out to me as being a great image of a very challenging subject, caught at just the right moment. The shot is technically spot on – focus in the right place, a lovely composition, and perfect exposure. The tiger at the rear really adds to the shot, but it would have been great if he had positioned himself so that he didn't mar the silhouette of the tiger at the front (seeing the shape of the ear would have added impact), but we all know animals just aren't co-operative in that way and overall this is a super image that the photographer should be proud of.
Doug's prize is a £200 voucher for Point 101
Photograph: Doug Nicholls Photograph: Action images