Photograph: Philip Bird Photograph: Action images
Natalie Mayer, judge: With the wonderful natural light and the stunning landscape, this photograph is almost there … what it lacks for me is a little more thought in the composition. It is a shame that the fourth tree is almost clipped off, and there is just a little too much space to the left which, because of the clipped tree, isn't balanced on the right. But the exposure is spot on, enhancing the natural glow of the evening, so the photographer should still feel very pleased with this image. Photograph: David Cantrille
Natalie Mayer, judge: I really like this image. The composition is lively yet extremely well balanced. The exposure has just the right mix of silhouette and detail. And the man is sharply in focus while the net isn't, which leads our eye immediately to the subject. The lovely pink sky fits the theme perfectly. Gorgeous image – you should be proud of this one.
Photograph: Gavin Burnett Photograph: Action images