Photograph: Dominic Burdon/GuardianWitness Photograph: ID101099ID101099/GuardianWitness
Natalie Mayer, judge: A stunning scene, captured at a splendid time of day. There is a small mark caused, most likely, by sensor dust, to the right on the mountains. This could be easily stamped off with the rubber stamp tool in Photoshop. I find the composition to be almost perfect, apart from one small matter. The spike of the temple is almost exactly on a level with the top of the mountains. Our eye can’t help but rest there and ponder this, yet it’s an inconsequential alignment. A little squat down, or standing on something, could have realigned this. Photograph: Dean Patrick/GuardianWitness
Natalie Mayer, judge: What a fascinating story about why these strange and grand columns are dotted on the landscape. A very pleasing image has been produced; good, clean and well balanced composition but… if the photographer would have taken one or two steps to the right, the column spacing would have balanced out to make the image properly symmetrical. Photograph: Elizabeth Purdie/GuardianWitness
Natalie Mayer, judge: I love this shot. Very Gursky. I’m compelled to keep looking, peeping into the windows to find a person, or look at the furniture and the scene. It’s a very simply, but effectively composed image. In a way, the curve of the windows and the odd dark room is a little disturbing to the eye and overall effect, which is a shame. But still, I find this a super picture worth a second and third look. Photograph: Slawek Kozdras/GuardianWitness