Luke Harding in Agra 

Fury as India cashes in on the allure of the Taj Mahal

Muslims and tourists driven out by huge rise in charge for admission to historic monument
  
  


It is Friday afternoon and at the Taj Mahal a large group of Muslims are gathering for prayers. Lurking in the shrubbery nearby, several squads of Indian police officers armed with sticks keep a close watch on the proceedings. A few small boys who arrive late plunge their feet into a ceremonial pool before dashing to the mosque, caps askew.

The crowd later spills out into the main courtyard. Several demonstrators unfurl a black banner and start shouting. They also wave posters carrying a picture of the Taj, beneath one of history's more esoteric slogans: 'Love & sacrefy [sic] symbol.' There is a brief standoff with the police, before the protesters surge out through the Taj's formal gardens and head down the road to deliver a petition to Agra's district magistrate.

These are troubled times indeed for India's most famous monument. And it is not just Agra's vociferous Muslim community which is unhappy. Last month the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) - the body responsible for preserving the country's heritage - dramatically raised admission prices for the Taj Mahal and other important sites.

Muslims who had previously got in free on Fridays along with everybody else suddenly found themselves charged 10 rupees. If you are poor, have to pray five times a day, and have a large family, this soon mounts up, they pointed out. Muslim leaders describe the move as an insidious blow to the freedom to practise their religion, and said it confirmed their worst suspicions about India's right-wing Hindu nationalist-led government.

But the ASI reserved its most blatant whammy for foreign tourists who now have to pay 960 rupees (£14) to get in. The fee used to be 15 rupees (22p).

Already many dazed backpackers, after checking their now out-of-date Lonely Planet guides, are giving the Taj a miss. The cost of a day's sightseeing in Agra, including the newly expensive Red Fort and the Mughal palace at nearby Fatehpur Sikri, now comes to £28.

The increase has provoked some foreigners to emulate the militant tactics adopted by Agra's Muslims. Two weeks ago a group of Japanese tourists staged a sit-down protest in front of the mausoleum, built by the Mughal King Shah Jahan to enshrine the body of his wife. Others, including Andrew Lubran, of Colchester, have written angry letters to the local Agra papers complaining of India's 'racist policy' to Westerners. The new Taj entrance fee was 'excessive and insulting', he said.

Agra's shopkeepers, tour guides, rickshaw wallahs and touts have been moaning too, as their business evaporates. Several cheap guesthouses next to the Taj have gone bust. 'We are the country of Gandhi. We have an ancient culture. We are against these racist entrance fees,' Abhinav Jain, who runs the Agra Marble Shoppe said.

The ASI has defended its new policy by pointing to the fact that other countries such as neighbouring Sri Lanka and Russia also charge a dual tariff. It cites the example of the Hermitage in St Petersburg, where non-Russians pay nearly £7, 10 times what the locals do.

'It's a great building but it's not worth 960 rupees to get in,' Oxford student Aoife Smith said yesterday, as she strolled past one of the Taj's minarets. The country's 14 world heritage sites, including the erotic temples at Khajuraho, and at Konarak, Orissa, are nearly £7 each. Other previously free lesser ruins cost more than £3.

Indian's tourism minister Ananth Kumar has been strangely reluctant to defend the new charges. When The Observer finally caught up with him, next to a tea urn at a party, and asked him how he justified the hike, he failed to answer, smiling glassily before moving off with a posse of grim-faced aides.

The ASI's director Komal Anand was more forthcoming and said the extra revenue would be 'ploughed back' into restoring India's 3,606 mostly crumbling monuments - a claim few tourism industry observers believe has much credibility.

Unless the Indian authorities back down, the affair threatens to destroy the classic India year out, as immortalised by William Sutcliffe and other traveller-novelists. Guides at the Taj Mahal estimate that 50-100 foreign students a day are now turning up at the red sandstone front gate - only to leave again without going inside.

'We were so disappointed by these price rises,' Helen Walton, 23, travelling round India with her boyfriend Miles Ross, 25, said. 'They were totally unexpected. No one minds paying a little bit more - say 100-200 rupees - but $5, $10, even $20 is totally out of backpackers' budgets. It's really sad, because it means we're simply not going to things at all, which can't be what the government wanted. We are now heading off to Nepal instead.'

The backlash has already spread as far as Britain, where last month angry tour operators bent Kumar's ear over breakfast in London. With brochures already printed, they complained that the extra entry fee costs would now come directly out of their profits. They also wondered how the hike could be reconciled with India's aim of increasing tourist numbers from 2.4 to 4 million. 'This is a huge blow to Indian tourism. We are very upset,' Arjun Sharma, of SITA Travels, explained. 'It comes on top of an increase in the Indian visa fee from £19 to £30.'

Most operators were now planning to drop several monuments from their future itineraries, he added.

Back at the Taj itself, as sun sets over the Yamuna River, and garlands of marigolds float downstream, the Muslim demonstrators are gradually dispersing. With each passing Friday it seems more likely that they will get their way. They, after all, have votes, unlike foreign backpackers.

Staff at the ASI ticket booth have already put up a homemade cardboard sign which reads: 'Fridays free' - even though they are supposed to charge. The walls outside the ticket grille have been daubed with graffiti, which reads 'Black Day' and - in Hindi - 'ASI thief'. No one wants to be beaten up next to the world's most famous monument to love.

'Muslim people made the Taj. Shah Jahan was a Muslim King,' Mehtab Pappu, 22, from Agra, said. 'All we want is to be allowed to come here and pray.'

What price a wonder of the world?

Other world attractions and what they charge...

The Colosseum in Rome, Italy: £3.15

The Great Wall of China: At the main tourist spot in Badaling admission is £2.05.

The Inca city of Machu Picchu, Peru: £6.80; students £3.40

The Parthenon in Athens: £3.58; students £1.79

Stonehenge in England: £4 for adults, £3 for students.

Walt Disney World, Florida: 1-day pass, adults (age 10 up) £33.09; children, £28.62.

The Millennium Dome, Greenwich, London: Adults £20, children £15.50

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*