First footing

What am I looking for as I roam Thailand, notebook and tape recorder in hand, on assignment for Lonely Planet?
  
  


What am I looking for as I roam Thailand, notebook and tape recorder in hand, on assignment for Lonely Planet?

Believe it or not, "unspoiled" beaches are the last thing I hope to find. Most "unspoiled" beaches I've come across in my two-plus decades of drifting through the kingdom were doomed before I ever got there. Doomed whether I wrote about them or not, doomed in the sense that their existence could not possibly be kept a secret for very long. I've never come across a beach that I hadn't already heard about from other travellers.

Can I preserve a beach by not writing about it? If I were the only person writing guidebooks about Thailand, it might be possible, but in a field crowded with competing guides, it's highly unlikely. But by writing about the fragility of the coastal ecosystem, and about the many threats a beach may face - not just from tourism, but from shrimp farming, charcoal manufacturing, and other enterprises - I might be able to contribute to an awareness that could lead to appropriate conservation measures.

Long before 20th Century Fox arrived at Ao Maya on Ko Phi-Phi Leh, I was writing about environmental devastation in Ko Phi-Phi - Hat Noppharat Thara National Marine Park. Yet every time I visited Phi-Phi, there were more tourists than ever, many of them carrying Lonely Planet guides advising them not to visit Phi-Phi.

Visitors continue to flood Phi-Phi because it is - or was - a pretty destination and the Thais have provided plenty of infrastructure catering to tourists. Take away that infrastructure and the numbers would plummet. Enforcing national park regulations in Thailand would go a very long way towards keeping the high worldwide demand for beach tourism from destroying the environment and diluting the culture.

A guidebook can only do so much. Some responsibility must be cultivated by the host country and by the visitors themselves.

As for pushing farther and farther towards the "undiscovered", I understand how people with a taste for adventure might feel when they come to a place and find a lot of people from their own culture there. I understand why people might get annoyed and bored by that. But when you want it to be all for you and you only - that I don't understand.

People use Lonely Planet to find new places - and then when they find anyone else there, they become angry with LP! Did Sal and Daffy in The Beach read about the Ang Thong Archipelago - the setting for the infamous beach in the novel - in their Lonely Planet guide, or did they find it on their own? They were looking for a place that wasn't in Lonely Planet, yet Ang Thong is in Lonely Planet and has been for years. It's also on all the maps.

This attitude, that you're going to find some untouched part of Asia that no one else will see, that it will be your own private little experience - it's a rather counterproductive, delusional, and perhaps hypocritical western idea. People imagine they want to visit a non-western society, and they want to make sure no other westerner is there but themselves.

The contradiction: If you're a westerner, and you're there, then your chosen spot is already "polluted". You're polluting it. Your moral choice: stay home, thereby restricting your knowledge of, and thus your participation in, the world outside your door; or travel consciously, learning what you can about the culture and environment, and treating both with respect. If you're looking for authentic Thailand, and having a hard time locating it, don't blame your guidebook. Blame your own imagination. It's easy enough to stay well off the package-tour circuit if you follow two simple rules.

Rule one: stay as far away from airports as possible. One reason three Andaman archipelagos, Tarutao, Similan, and Surin, have remained relatively free of environmental (and cultural) degradation is because you can't fly there, and you can't reach them in a short boat ride, either.

Rule two: Forget about palm trees. Palm trees fuel the European taste for the exotic. Meanwhile Thais are bored with palms, which are no more exciting to them than your neighbourhood elms. You'll find all of the non-palmy beaches of south Thailand - the ones lined with casuarina or sea pines, from Prachuap Khiri Khan to Narathiwat - to be so laid-back you may have to bring your own lunch.

And if you do sniff out a beach that satisfies you, don't tell Daffy.

• Joe Cummings is the author of the Lonely Planet guide to Thailand and Thailand's Islands & Beaches . Guardian readers can order The Lonely Planet Guide to Thailand for £13.99 or The Lonely Planet Beaches of Thailand for £9.99 and receive a free Lonely Planet Thai phrasebook worth £3.99. Call free on 0800 3166102 or send your order with a UK cheque payable to The Guardian CultureShop to, 250 Western Avenue, London, W3 6EE. Please add 99p UK p&p per order.

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*