The best way to find a good hotel is by personal recommendation and The Good Hotel Guide could be described as word-of-mouth in print. A good hotel was defined by Hilary Rubinstein, who founded the Guide 24 years ago, as: 'Where the guest comes first.'
We look for hotels of unusual character and quality. They are usually on the small side and owner-managed; almost no hotels in the book belong to a chain, since these usually fail to provide the welcome and care for guests' comfort that can be found in the best of the small, individually owned hotels. Most have been recommended by correspondents who have taken the trouble to write to us. We verify and collate the reports, making an anonymous overnight inspection where necessary.
The Guide is independent: we accept no free hospitality, contributors are not paid for writing to us and hotels do not pay for their entry. This gives us the freedom to criticise where appropriate. The entries are updated each year. Hotels are dropped if critical reports outweigh those in favour, if we have had no reports for some time or if there has been a change of ownership, unless we are sure that standards have been maintained. Despite the name, we also include inns, guest houses and B&Bs, since many of our readers like their good value and lack of formality.
Each year 10 special hotels are given our César award for excellence. Some of the winners in the 2001 edition are included in this selection (they are marked with a laurel leaf).
Town house hotels
One of the interesting trends in recent years has been the development of the small townhouse hotel in major cities.
1 Hotel on the Park
Evesham Road, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire. GL52 2AH
01242 518898; fax 01242 511526
email stay@hotelonthepark.co.uk
www.hotelonthepark.co.uk
Regency townhouse across road from Pittville Park, five minutes' walk from centre. Elegant decor (fine antiques, swagged curtains); friendly owner, Darryl Gregory; small garden. Contemporary British cooking. Thirteen bedrooms. B&B £48.31 to £86.71. Set dinner £22.50.
2 Haley's
Shire Oak Road, Headingley, Leeds, West Yorkshire LS6 2DE
0113 278 4446; fax 0113 275 3342
email info@haleys.co.uk
www.haleys.co.uk
John Appleyard's turreted Victorian house in leafy suburb near university. Open fires, period furniture, lavish drapes. Friendly staff; very comfortable rooms. Lounge/bar, library, restaurant with modern cooking. Twenty-nine bedrooms. B&B £42.50 to £120. Set dinner £25.
3 Hazlitt's
6 Frith Street, London W1V 5TZ
020 743 41771; fax 020 7439 1524
email reservations@hazlitts.co.uk
www.hazlittshotel.com
In Soho: three eighteenth-century terrace houses (the essayist lived in one), now a small, trendy hotel. Edwardian decor. Continental breakfast (£7.25) brought to the bedroom. Twenty-three bedrooms: single £140, double £175, suite £300.
4 Number Sixteen
16 Sumner Place, London SW7 3EG
020 75895232; fax 020 75848615
email reservations@numbersixteenhotel.co.uk
www.numbersixteenhotel.co.uk
In residential street near South Kensington underground station, one of London's first townhouse hotels: attractive conversion of four houses. Conservatory; flower garden with fountain; chintzy lounge, library. Thirty-six bedrooms. B&B £85 to £143.
5 Eleven Didsbury Park
11 Didsbury Park, Didsbury Village, Manchester M20 5LH
0161 4487711; fax 0161 4488282
email enquiries@elevendidsburypark.com
www.elevendidsburypark.com
Eamonn and Sally O'Loughlin's Victorian townhouse in conservation area, 20 minutes by bus from centre. Informal; modern decor. Terrace, walled garden, rooftop terrace with hot tub; pleasant breakfast room; snack menu. Fourteen bedrooms: double £69.50 to £119.50.
6 Horton Grange
Seaton Burn, Newcastle upon Tyne NE13 6BU
01661 860686; fax 01661 860308
email andrew@horton-grange.co.uk;
www.horton-grange.co.uk
In open country six miles north of centre, Sue and Andrew Shilton's stone-built house in four-acre grounds with water garden. Home-like feel; good breakfasts and dinners in conservatory style restaurant. Thirteen bedrooms. B&B £37.50 to £74. Set dinner £34.
7 Morgans
The Townhouse, 34 The Ropewalk, The Park, Nottingham NG1 5DW
0115 957 0017; fax 0115 957 0018
email info@morgans34.com
www.morgans34.com
Kathy Morgan's Grade II listed nineteenth-century house on leafy ridge above the Park (conservation area). Stylish conversion retaining original features. Five spacious rooms with big bed, fresh fruit, flowers, excellent bathroom. Complimentary drinks in panelled lounge. Good breakfast. Electronically gated carpark. B&B £55 to £120.
8 The Mansion House
Thames Street, Poole, Dorset BH15 1JN
01202 685666; fax 01202 665709
email enquiries@themansionhouse.co.uk
www.themansionhouse.co.uk
Eighteenth-century townhouse in quiet cul-de-sac. Grand staircase; stylish lounge. Exemplary management by Jackie Godden; interesting cooking by her husband, Gerry, in restaurant and bar/bistro. Thirty-two bedrooms. B&B £44.50 to £88. Set meal £16.25 to £23.50.
9 The Bonham
25 Drumsheugh Gardens, Edinburgh EH3 7RN
0131 226 6050; fax 0131 226 6080
email reserve@thebonham.com
www.thebonham.com
Posh, chic and pricey: two Victorian buildings in quiet square, now designer hotel. Paintings by Scottish artists throughout. Californian-inspired food in restaurant (open to the public). Forty-eight bedrooms, full of hi-tech. B&B £77.50 to£165. À la carte meal £34.
10 The Town House
4 Hughenden Terrace, Hyndland, Glasgow G12 9XR
0141 357 0862; fax 0141 339 9605
email hospitality@thetownhouseglasgow.com
www.thetownhouseglasgow.com
Not smart, but reasonably priced and welcoming: Michael Ferguson's B&B, in Victorian sandstone building on quiet street in conservation area. Deep cornices, high ceilings, carved architraves, simple furnishings, easy parking. Eight bedrooms. B&B £34 to £58.
Romantic hotels
A selection of fine buildings in a lovely setting; you can get married in some of them.
1 Burgh Island Hotel
Burgh Island, Bigbury-on-Sea, Devon TQ7 4BG
01548 810514, fax 01548 810243
email reception@burghisland.com
www.burghisland.com
Lovingly restored by Tony and Beatrice Porter: Art Deco extravaganza on private island in Bigbury Bay. Twenties/Thirties furniture, fittings and cocktails. Peacock-domed palm court; sun lounge; dinner in ballroom (formal dress). Natural swimming pool in rocks; beach. Fifteen suites. Dinner, B&B £110 to £172.
2 Gravetye Manor
Vowels Lane, East Grinstead West Sussex RH19 4LJ
01342 810567; fax 01342 810080
email gravetye@relaischateaux.fr
Handy for honeymooners (12 miles from Gatwick airport): Peter Herbert's luxury hotel in magnificent grounds designed by William Robinson. Tudor drawing room with carved wood. Eighteen bedrooms: double £120 to £280. Breakfast £14 to £16. Set dinner £38 or £48.
3 Combe House
Gittisham, near Honiton, Devon EX14 3AD
01404 540400; fax 01404 46004
email stay@thishotel.com
www.thishotel.com
Grade I listed Elizabethan manor house with nineteenth-century additions. On hill in vast Devon estate (woodland, meadows, pastures with Arabian horses). Panelled public rooms have plastered ceilings, ancestral portraits, antiques. Friendly owners, Ruth and Ken Hunt, and staff. Fifteen bedrooms. Dinner, B&B £83 to £130.
4 Hambleton Hall
Hambleton, Oakham, Rutland LE15 8TH
01572 756991; fax 01572 724721
email hotel@hambletonhall.com
www.hambletonhall.com
Victorian pile on peninsula in Rutland Water, now Tim and Stefa Hart's luxury hotel: sophisticated decor; Michelin-starred restaurant; manicured gardens with terrace (alfresco breakfasts), swimming pool. Seventeen bedrooms. B&B £85 to£160. Set dinner £35 to £40.
5 Bolebroke Mill
Edenbridge Road, Hartfield, East Sussex TN7 4JP
01892 770425; fax 01892 770425
email b+b@bolebrokemill.demon.co.uk
Domesday-old watermill, mill house and Elizabethan barn by tree-lined stream with ducks and geese. Now David and Christine Cooper's B&B. Five cottagey bedrooms; two up steep loft ladder. Award-winning breakfast, communally served. B&B double £65 to £78.
6 Lavenham Priory
Water Street, Lavenham, Suffolk CO10 9RW
01787 247404; fax 01787 248472
email tim.pitt@btinternet.com
www.lavenhampriory.co.uk
Lavishly restored by Tim and Gilli Pitt: Grade I listed thirteenth-century house: Elizabethan wall paintings, oak floors, Jacobean staircase, exotic beds (four-poster, bateau, polonaise). Lovely garden. Communal breakfast; dinner by arrangement. Five bedrooms. B&B £39 to £69.
7 The Beetle and Wedge
Ferry Lane, Moulsford-on-Thames, Oxfordshire OX10 9JF
01491 651381; fax 01491 651376
In magical Thames-side setting on manicured lawns: Richard and Kate Smith's old inn. French cooking in main restaurant; informal food in Boathouse; water garden for summer meals. Handy for Heathrow. Fourteen bedrooms. B&B £67.50 to £120, double £135 to £150. À la carte meal £31.50 to £48.50.
8 Ynyshir Hall
Eglwysfach, near Machynlleth, Powys SY20 8TA
01654 781209; fax 01654 781366
email info@ynyshir-hall.co.uk
www.ynyshir-hall.co.uk
Rob and Joan Reen's white Georgian longhouse in landscaped gardens on Dyfi estuary, surrounded by RSPB reserve. Bright colours, paintings, excellent meals, lavish breakfasts. Ten bedrooms. B&B £60 to £135. Dinner £36.
9 Bodysgallen Hall
Llanrhos, Llandudno, Conwy LL30 1RS
01492 584466; fax 01492 582519
email info@bodysgallen.com
www.bodysgallen.com
In large hillside park: seventeenth-century Grade 1 listed mansion, immaculately restored (panelled rooms, ancestral portraits, mullioned windows), now a luxury hotel. Spa (54ft swimming pool, gym, beauty salons), knot garden, rose garden. Thirty-six bedrooms: single £99-£104, double £140-£235. Breakfast £13.50. Dinner £33.90.
10 Ardanaiseig
Kilchrenan by Taynuilt, Argyll and Bute PA35 1HE
01866 833333; fax 01866 833222
email ardanaiseig@clara.net
www.ardanaiseig.com
In huge estate on Loch Awe: Scottish baronial mansion in glorious, rambling gardens; highland cattle in pasture; classical Greek-style amphitheatre (performances of song and dance held). Sixteen bedrooms. B&B: £73 to £120. Set dinner £35.
Breakfast
All too often, after a good dinner and a comfortable night, breakfast is a letdown, with off-hand service, packaged jams and butters, commercial juice and toast, and teabag tea. In the places listed below, it is something special.
1 Little Barwick House
Barwick, Somerset BA22 9TD
01935 423902; fax 01935 420908
Georgian house in garden near Yeovil: run by Tim and Emma Ford, with emphasis on food. Breakfast includes fresh orange juice (seconds offered) and they know how to scramble eggs. Six bedrooms. B&B £42 to £46.50; D,B&B £60 to £66.50.
2 Michael's Nook
Grasmere, Cumbria LA22 9RP
015394 35496; fax 015394 35645
email m-nook@wordsworth-grasmere.co.uk
www.grasmere-hotels.co.uk
Full of character: stone house in gardens above Grasmere. Run by Reg Gifford. Excellent modern cooking in Michelin-starred restaurant. Breakfast as good: freshly squeezed juices, leaf tea, cold meats, cheeses, impeccably cooked eggs. Fourteen bedrooms. Dinner, B&B £90 to £205.
3 The Old Rectory
Hopesay, Craven Arms, Shropshire
01588 660245; fax 01588 660502
Home-made yogurt and preserves, fruit compote, home-baked bread and traditional cooked dishes are served by Roma and Michael Villar at their guest house in a hamlet above Clun valley. Sophisticated house party-style evening meal, with good wine, reasonably priced. Landscaped gardens. Three bedrooms. B&B £37.50. Set dinner £22.50.
4 Penrhos Court
Kington, Herefordshire HR5 3LH
01544 230720; fax 01544 230754
email martin@penrhos.co.uk
www.penrhos.co.uk
Tranquil collection of ancient buildings around pond with wildlife: now Martin Griffiths and Daphne Lambert's smoke-free, Muzak-free, eco-friendly hotel. Good organic dinners. Breakfast has freshly squeezed fruit and vegetable juices (eg, cucumber), wholemeal bread, organic honey and preserves; no fry-up, but Welsh rarebit or tofu sausages. 15 bedrooms. Dinner, B&B from £80.
5 Lea Hill Hotel
Membury, near Axminster, Devon EX13 7AQ
01404 881881; fax 01404 881890
www.leahillhotel.co.uk
In large grounds on hilltop, in designated area of outstanding natural beauty: Chris and Sue Hubbard's fourteenth-century thatched longhouse (beams, flagstone floors, inglenook fireplaces). Good dinners. Breakfasts include freshly squeezed orange juice, local sausages and black pudding, Manx kippers, smoked Finnan haddock. Eleven bedrooms, most with private patio or garden. B&B £56 to £68. Dinner, B&B £78 to £89.
6 Howard's House
Teffont Evias, Wiltshire SP3 5RJ
01722 716392; fax 01722 716820
email paul.firmin@virgin.net
www.howardshousehotel.co.uk
In picture-postcard village near Salisbury, quirky Swiss-style building (steeply pitched, broad-eaved roof), in garden by River Teff. Informally run by owner/chef Paul Firmin. Excellent dinners. Freshly squeezed orange juice and well-presented cooked dishes for breakfast. Nine bedrooms. B&B £47.50 to £75. Set dinner £19.95.
7 The Old Vicarage
66 Church Square, Rye, East Sussex TN31 7HF
01797 222119; fax 01797 227466
email oldvicaragerye@tesco.net
www.homepages.tesco.net~oldvicaragerye
Paul and Julia Masters's pink B&B in eighteenth-century ex-vicarage. Breakfast, in bay-windowed room by garden, has properly brewed tea, home-made scones, bread and jams, free-range eggs, award-winning sausages. Tea on arrival, evening sherry, morning newspaper, included in price: B&B £18.50 to £37.
8 Sharrow Bay
Ullswater, near Penrith, Cumbria CA10 2LZ
01768 486301; fax 01768 486349
email enquiries@sharrow-bay.com
www.sharrow-bay.com
The original country house hotel, pampering and luxurious. Michelin-starred restaurant with lavish menus. Breakfast with veteran owner Brian Sack in attendance, white-coated waiters, fresh juices, fruit, porridge with cream, huge range of cooked dishes. Twenty-six bedrooms. Dinner, B&B £120 to £145.
9 Three Chimneys Restaurant and House
Over-by, Colbost, Isle of Skye, Highland IV55 8ZT
01470 511258; fax 01470 511358
email eatandstay@threechimneys.co.uk
www.threechimneys.co.uk
On edge of sea loch (much wildlife): restaurant with six luxury suites in house across courtyard. Brilliant modern design. Very good dinners in beamed, candlelit dining rooms. Breakfast has porridge with cream, smoked duck, venison and salmon, home-made oatcakes and jams. B&B double £130 to £155. À la carte dinner £45.
10 Clifton House
Viewfield Street, Nairn, Highland IV12 4HW
01667 453119; fax 01667 452836
email macintyre@clifton-hotel.co.uk
www.clifton-hotel.co.uk
Wonderfully eccentric hotel in rose-covered Victorian stone villa. Octogenarian owner J. Gordon Macintyre presides over good restaurant, occasional theatricals. Breakfasts (no time limit) include large choice of teas, porridge, home-made oatcakes, free-range eggs, fresh kippers. Twelve bedrooms. Dinner, B&B £85.