Natalie Mayer, judge: Lovely classic composition, and a nice relaxed expression. The depth of field works well and brings out the subject beautifully. A little lightening and a tiny dodge to bring out the whites of the eyes would really bring this image to life Photograph: Goncalo Diniz
Natalie Mayer, judge: This is an eye-catchingly composed image, with more than one point of interest. Interesting to contemplate the creation of such an elaborate book, and the dirty fingernails of the owner – it invokes a sense of interest about the book's holder Photograph: Dennis Cohen
Natalie Mayer, judge: This one is a clear winner for me. Awesome image! I love everything that it so unselfconsciously captures. There are so many fun and interesting things going on. Love the spilling pint glass, the nonchalant photographer, the blow up shark fight, the cute girl, the cheeky mate … loads of fun, and really a good capture of a culture lots of us have felt part of at some time or other Photograph: Jacob Cockle