Natalie Mayer, judge: I love the tones in this image, absolutely beautiful. And the action-interaction captured is gorgeous. The only thing that doesn't really work for me is the square crop. The harsh vignetting draws your eye to the top of the image, which then follows down to the bright centre of the image (which is empty and not requiring attention). A much more satisfying crop would be to a landscape format, from just behind the right-hand elephant's ear, and about 1cm above their heads. This keeps your attention firmly on the flow of the tusks and trunks, and the fact that the elephants would be now more off-centre prevents our eye from seeking a symmetry which isn't quite there. This is an image to be proud of – spend a little on some good printing and framing and be proud! Photograph: Jeremy Farrance
Natalie Mayer, judge: This is a stunning scene and the photographer has given it a fantastic perspective with clever framing. Lovely image. Photograph: Andrew Styan
Natalie Mayer, judge: This month's theme of nature has generated some wonderful entries. This one stood out as a winner for its clever use of and understanding of light. The bird just has its head peeping in a shaft of light, and has been cleverly and precisely captured through the leaves and branches. Any movement up or down (of which I'm sure there was much) could have hidden his head either in shadow or behind foliage, and that kind of precision deserves recognition. The shallow depth of field serves to emphasise perfectly the subject, and the exposure is spot on – not easy with so much light and shade to fool the camera's light meter. Fine work. Photograph: Matthew Fleet