On guide patrol…

Toothbrush. Ticket. Travel guide. Most of us wouldn't leave home without one. But which is the best?
  
  


The shortlist of five titles for the Travelex Guide Book of the Year competition, organised in association with The Observer and Books etc, has been named. The judges were looking for a book that would excite interest in a country while satisfying the need for practical information. The winner will be announced in Escape on 25 March.

The judges were Desmond Balmer, Travel Editor of The Observer; Gerry Conroy, Travelex's Group Director of Retail Operations; Jackie Crank, manager of the Broadgate branch of Books etc and Bing Taylor, managing director of Phoenix Press.

Cuba

Rough Guides, £10.99

As always from the series that won last year's award, this is the complete guide for the thinking traveller. The writing is enthusiastic and upbeat providing a fascinating cultural and political background. Everything is covered from music to sport. It will help find the hidden or alternative Cuba with no stone unturned ('take the left-hand fork at the petrol station'). This is especially helpful if you land in a small regional town where the state-run restaurants are poor. But this does make it the heaviest of the five guides shortlisted: 'I would read it before I travelled and take notes,' said Bing Taylor. A redesign gives a cleaner look but the small typeface is difficult to read.

Istanbul
Time Out, £10.99
A new edition from an established series. The writing is quirky but captivating. 'You can hear the author's voice,' said Jackie Crank. The maps are excellent (you wouldn't need to buy another one). The history of the city is told with a lightness of touch and a gentle humour in the sidebars: 'atta Turk!' about the founder of modern Turkey, 'at the drop of a hat' about the fez and 'Uefa yes, EU no' about the links with Europe. As you would expect from Time Out , the listings are comprehensive but never boring. This was also the best mix of photographs and text. The cover is dull but, worse, the guide contains some naff local adverts. Any fears about this influencing the verdicts are soon lifted, however. Take this from the description of the Ceylan Inter-Continental: 'The style is brash, the tone set by a horrendous golden staircase spiralling its way upwards from the lobby area.' The hotel's advert on the inside back cover features a picture of the guilty staircase.

Costa Rica
The National Geographic Traveler, £12.99
The photographs, as you would expect from the National Geographic library, are outstanding. These are matched by personable writing ('I felt the rapport you might have with a good tour guide,' said Gerry Conroy) and thoughtful presentation. The book excited interest in this haven for wildlife. There were useful sections devoted to specific subjects - the world of butterflies, volcanoes and the grano de oro (the coffee bean of gold). The maps were clear and the regional guides provided a sense of place equipping the reader to plan a visit. The range of the listings for hotels and restaurants seemed limited and there was no phrase book or food glossary. The high production values made this good value at £12.99.

Hiking in the USA
Lonely Planet, £14.99
An interesting move by Lonely Planet into new terrain, an enticing guide to the Great Outdoors, an often overlooked aspect of the American experience. 'This is something I wouldn't normally think about but it made it seem possible. By the end I thought, I'm going,' said Jackie Crank. The introduction sets up the history and geography of the westward expansion of the United States with good detail about the flora, fauna and wildlife. The layout and mapping have been thoughtfully assembled. The only drawback was the sheer volume of information required for day-by-day trekking. The project seemed too ambitious - who is it aimed at? It felt more like a reference book.

New York
AA Spiral Guide, £9.99
Sharp bite-sized information, ideal for the quick trip. The spiral format was enjoyed, thanks to the good paper quality. 'You can keep it in your pocket as you travel around,' said Gerry Conroy. Some of the detail was excellent, as were the walking map guides. Read this on the plane over and you could learn how to avoid the queues at the base of the Empire State Building or find the hidden Campbell apartment bar with its Tiffany stained-glass windows at Grand Central Station. Yet some of the judgments seemed uneven: 'They've recommended the worst restaurant in Brooklyn,' said New Yorker Bing Taylor. 'And do we need to know what a hot dog looks like?'

 

Leave a Comment

Required fields are marked *

*

*