Whether you're off on a business trip or a family holiday, the last thing you want to worry about is whether your baggage will survive its handling. Towing handles, wheels and foot studs are the commonest casualties of the baggage carousel, according to British Airways and luggage maker Antler. Hard cases tend to fare less well than the softer fabric types because they are made of either polypropylene, which can crack, or metal, which tends to dent. A soft case, made from either nylon or polyester, is the lighter option, and will withstand impact better than hard cases because of its "give".
Generally, the cases we tested fared well: the Samsonite Nauka was the only one to suffer any wheel damage. Some cases suffered a certain amount of denting or distortion of the frame, but most came away with nothing worse than heavy scuffing and scratching on the plastic trim and piping. Out and about, all the cases passed their road tests, easily navigating curves, corners and different road surfaces. Unless you are unlucky enough to get caught in a torrential downpour, your clothes should escape a soaking, as most remained dry in the main compartment.
Paying around the £100 mark will buy you a robust, manoeuvrable case with useful extra features. There are bargains to be had, however, such as the Marks and Spencer Stradalite case, which, at £70, performed nearly as well as the trendy Tumi case, which is a hefty £686.
The Good Housekeeping Institute put nine medium (one-week) and four small (weekend) trolley suitcases through testing designed to simulate the wear and tear of several years' travel. Hard and soft cases of different sizes were filled with towels, clothes, shoes, toiletries and books, and taken to London City airport. The cases were then sent through a loop from check-in, across the tarmac, and back to the arrivals lounge. Back at the Good Housekeeping Institute, the cases were dragged up and down stairs, dropped on all sides from a height of 1m, and showered with half a litre of water to assess their durability and water resistance. They were then wheeled round London streets to assess their manoeuvrability.
All suitcases tested have top and side handles, a rigid towing handle and straps inside to hold the contents in place. All dimensions are given in the form height x width x depth.
Medium cases: under £100
Metropolis EVA trolley case 5381
£18
Score: 75/100
Technical data
Soft case. 73x44x26cm. Capacity: 83 litres. Weight when empty: 5kg. External features: two in-line wheels and padlock. Internal features: one mesh pocket and three small pockets in lid. One-year guarantee.
Pros
Easy to pull and remained stable on different surfaces. Towing handle easy to extend and retract. Good range of pockets inside case - ideal for stowing away shoes or small items.
Cons
Plastic piping on back of case split, and back corner dented on impact. Towing handle does not stay locked in position when case is being pushed. Elasticated straps difficult to adjust around clothing. No external pockets.
Verdict Good value, but won't stand up to rough treatment.
Stockists 01279 441 411 No website.
Medium cases: under £100
Skyflite 66cm trolley case
£70
Score: 80/100
Technical data
Soft case. 66x47x25cm. Capacity: 80 litres. Weight when empty: 5.3kg. External features: two in-line wheels, expandable pocket. Internal features: one mesh pocket in lid, removable wet pocket. Three-year guarantee.
Pros
Good manoeuvrability on all surfaces. Minimal scuffing on fabric, and plastic protectors around wheels. Internal straps are easy to fit together. External pockets can be locked. Concealed luggage label on back.
Cons
Some buckling to frame on bottom right corner at front. Difficult to extend and retract towing handle, which cannot be locked in different positions. Elastic parts on handles sit tight against the case.
Verdict Good external storage.
Stockists 020-8527 9017 No website.
Medium cases: under £100
Antler Firenze Superlite large roller case
£85
Score: 82/100
Technical data
Soft case. 71x48x29cm. Capacity: 100 litres. Weight when empty: 4.4kg. External features: two in-line wheels, padlock. Internal features: one mesh pocket in lid, one wet pocket. Five-year guarantee.
Pros
Lightest of the medium cases tested. Easy to manoeuvre. "Piggyback" strap allows you to attach extra bags when travelling. Concealed luggage label at back.
Cons
Both sides of case dented heavily at the back. Scuffing on plastic trim around wheels. No external pockets. Towing handle does not stay in locked position when case is being pushed.
Verdict Lightweight for a case of this size.
Stockists 0161 764 5241 www.antler.co.uk
Medium cases: over £100
Antler XtraLite Zip longhaul roller case
£115
Score: 85/100
Technical data
Hard case. 74x51x30cm. Capacity: 113 litres. Weight when empty: 5.3kg. External features: two in-line wheels, combination padlock, base stand. Internal features: one wet pocket, divider. Five-year guarantee.
Pros
Excellent durability - no damage to frame and minimal scuffing. Good manoeuvrability on smooth surfaces. Largest capacity of cases tested. Towing handle can be locked in several positions.
Cons
Laborious to pull on uneven surfaces as the base stand catches on the ground. Towing handle slightly awkward to extend and retract as you have to push a button to release it. No external pockets.
Verdict Large capacity case.
Stockists 0161 764 5241 www.antler.co.uk
Medium cases: over £100
Samsonite 800 series Xylem 75cm upright Uktais
£195
Score: 82/100
Technical data
Soft case. 75x45x28cm. Capacity: 88 litres. Weight when empty: 6kg. External features: two in-line wheels, one combination padlock, one zip pocket at rear. Internal features: two pockets, divider, suit hanger. Three-year guarantee.
Pros
Good manoeuvrability on all surfaces. Frame and wheels remained intact during tests. Internal straps easy to fit together and adjust around clothing. "Piggyback" strap allows user to attach extra bags easily. Useful pockets, suit hanger and divider inside.
Cons
Heavy scuffing on plastic areas around wheels, some scuffing on metal trim on towing handle. Light silver finish looks grubby after tests. Wide towing handle is awkward to use. Towing handle stiff to extend and can't be locked in different positions.
Verdict Stylish silver look, useful suit hanger.
Stockists 01895 855 755 www.samsonite.co.uk
Medium cases: over £100
4-Runner Suiter trolley, Atlantic Infinity IV range
£219
Score: 89/100
Technical data
Soft case. 66x49x26cm. Capacity: 100 litres. Weight when empty: 7.3kg. External features: two in-line, two multidirectional wheels, combination padlock, three front pockets. Internal features: two pockets. Life guarantee.
Pros
No damage to wheels or frame from tests. Can be used on either two or four wheels, which improves manoeuvrability. Towing handle can be zipped away to prevent damage. Useful combination padlock.
Cons
Heaviest model tested. A lot of scuffing on corners of case and on wheel trim. Manoeuvrability reduced on rough surfaces when using four wheels. Towing handle cannot be locked in different positions.
Verdict Good performer. Four-wheeled drive. Useful extra pockets.
Stockists 01462 832 000 www.atlanticluggage.com
Weekend cases
Marks & Spencer Stradalite rollercase
£70
Score: 85/100
Technical data
Soft case. 57x40x20 cm, Capacity: 46 litres. Weight when empty: 3.6kg. External features: two in-line wheels, combination padlock, "piggyback" strap. Internal features: one mesh pocket in lid, one removable wet pocket. One-year guarantee.
Pros
Excellent durability - no damage to frame or wheels. Minimal scuffing to trim and wheels. Towing handle can be locked in several positions. Good manoeuvrability on all surfaces, easy and lightweight to pull on all surfaces. Useful combination padlock.
Cons
No external pockets.
Verdict Excellent performance for the price.
Stockists 020-7268 1234 www.marksandspencer.co.uk
Weekend cases
Samsonite 350 series Nauka 55cm
£79
Score: 79/100
Technical data
Soft case. 55x38x20 cm. Capacity: 32 litres. Weight when empty: 3.4kg. External features: four multi-directional wheels, combination lock, "piggyback" strap, two front pockets. Internal features: one pocket. Three-year guarantee.
Pros
Lightweight model. Multidirectional wheels allow case to turn corners easily on all surfaces. Built-in combination lock on side of the case allows user to lock the zips into the case for extra security.
Cons
Back right corner dented and one wheel damaged during tests, which made the case difficult to pull at times. Zip on one front pocket does not close properly when strap is extended, allowing water to get into pocket. Smallest capacity of weekend models. Internal straps awkward to lock together and undo.
Verdict Good security features.
Stockists 01895 855 755 www.samsonite.co.uk
Weekend cases
Tumi Wheel-a-way
£686
Score: 87/100
Soft case. 56x36x25cm. Capacity: 70 litres. Weight when empty: 4.9kg. External features: two in-line wheels, combination padlock, expandable pocket, "piggyback" strap, two front pockets. Internal features: two removable pockets, two pockets in divider, suit hanger. Lifetime guarantee.
Pros
Excellent durability - no frame or wheel damage. Very good manoeuvrability and easy to use on all surfaces tested, coping well with kerbs and uneven surfaces. Internal straps easy to lock together and adjust around clothing. Useful "piggyback" straps and expandable pocket.
Cons
Plastic trim surrounding one wheel became chipped. Some water seeped through zip on front pocket. Extending and retracting the towing handle with one hand is impossible as you have to push a button to release it.
Verdict Expensive, but a good performer.
Stockists 020-8731 3500 www.tumi.com
Also tested
Medium (one-week) suitcases: Delsey Mobility Silver: £175, 73/100 Pierre Cardin Professional Traveller: £49.99, 74/100 Salisbury Explorer Medium Multipull: £42, 67/100
Small (weekend) suitcases: Falcon 2in1 Medium luggage trolley case with laptop case 1018: £144.95, 54/100
The questions people ask
1. What features should I look for when buying a suitcase?
A suitcase with an expandable pocket such as the Skyflite, Atlantic or Tumi is versatile. A "piggyback" strap is useful for attaching extra smaller bags to your main case. Good-sized external pockets allow quick access to items you need to get to frequently, but you won't be able to put anything breakable in them - or anything of any value, unless they're lockable. Multidirectional wheels that turn 360 degrees and adjustable-length towing handles give greater control when you are on the move. Suit hangers and dividers will help keep your clothes looking good.
2. How can I make sure my luggage stays secure?
Replace small locks with more robust combination padlocks or choose a case with an integral locking system. Always put a label with your name and outward destination on the outside. Never fill in your home details on an external luggage label until your return journey - but attach a label with your home or contact address to the inside in case your luggage gets lost. For details of items you must not take into the cabin, as well as tips on travelling safely, contact your airline or get a copy of the Civil Aviation Authority's Travelling Safely leaflet on 020-7453 6030, or at www.caa.co.uk
3.Do you have any tips for packing a suitcase?
Try packing heavy and bulky items against the hinge so that they are at the bottom of the case when you stand it up. Use the bottom half of the suitcase for jumpers, trousers and accessories. In the top half, fold up dresses and suits as flat as possible. Use socks to fill up any gaps, as this will stop items shifting about. Finally, don't forget to check your baggage allowance - it's usually stated on your ticket, and you can check with the airline. It is also worth confirming whether your weekend case is small enough to go in the cabin for a quick getaway on arrival.
· Next month's product test, to be published on July 2, will be charcoal barbecues. For subscriptions to Good Housekeeping, call 01858 438844 or visit www.goodhousekeeping.co.uk