It sounds great. A travel agent who visits your home to discuss your holiday requirements. Someone who can get to know your favourite destinations and recommend great hotels. No queuing in your local agency or hanging on the telephone for a consultant to answer an expensive 0870 number.
Many of this new breed of 'personal travel advisers' bring along holiday videos and laptops to check availability from your sitting room. It sounds a hassle-free way to book your place in the sun. But is it? I went undercover to find out.
The request: A two-week honeymoon in Italy. I'd like to visit Venice, Florence and spend some time on Lake Garda. My fiancé is a keen swimmer so I want a hotel with a swimming pool on the lake and small hotels with character (but not necessarily cheap ones) in Venice and Florence.
The budget: £3,000.
The contenders: A personal travel adviser who can visit my home, a high-street travel agent and a specialist tour operator.
The at-home service
Personal travel adviser Natalie arrived the day after we talked briefly on the telephone about my holiday request, carrying brochures on Italy in a rather unimpressive plastic bag.
She admitted she was not an Italy expert but the brochures were from Citalia and Magic of Italy, two specialist operators, as well as Crystal Holidays, which plans personal itineraries.
One brochure had the remains of a rival travel agent's sticker on it, which she had tried unsuccessfully to remove. She explained she had picked it up from a local travel agent to avoid getting a bulk supply delivered. Not very professional.
She had highlighted the relevant pages on the Italian cities and lakes, and brought along a small map of Italy printed off the internet, which showed Venice and Florence in relation to the lakes.
Natalie, who works on commission rather than charges a fee, seemed quite nervous, and admitted this was her first home visit. She asked me few questions about my requirements. I told her the size of my budget and what kind of hotels I liked.
She reassured me that my £3,000 budget would be more than adequate. 'Most of my clients only want to spend £200 on their holiday,' she said. Most of the hotels would probably offer us champagne or flowers, as it was our honeymoon.
After nearly an hour she left, giving me a smart silver-coloured business card and promising to get back to me with quotes as soon as possible.
It took nearly a week to receive my first sample itinerary, from Magic of Italy via email. The three-star hotels in the locations requested were for 14 nights, not the 13 nights I had asked for. The Lake Garda hotel had no pool.
After reiterating my requests, it took another week to finalise itineraries with Citalia and Magic of Italy. Both Lake Garda hotels offered by these companies had pools, but according to the brochures, neither would be open during our visit.
Verdict: Not very impressive. Although Natalie was friendly, polite and very willing to help, her lack of knowledge of Italy let her down. There was a lot of to-ing and fro-ing with the tour operator (she had to keep faxing them her requests), which meant it took nearly a week to receive my first itinerary.
The strangest thing was that I had £3,000 to spend, and the first quote came in at less than £2,000, staying in three-star hotels. This was my honeymoon - I was prepared to pay for more expensive hotels. I wasn't after a bargain.
Satisfaction rating: 5/10
The high-street agent
I went to Going Places, which is changing its name to Mytravel. There was only one other customer in the shop when I walked into the Strand branch, in central London, on a Tuesday afternoon. I was served immediately by a confident young woman called Kay. I told her my requirements and budget, and she immediately picked up the Cresta Italy brochure, saying this firm was part of the Going Places group and could tailor an itinerary for me.
Kay steered me towards three-star hotels, but I said I wanted something special for my honeymoon. She telephoned a Cresta consultant who recommended four-star hotels in Venice, Florence and on Lake Garda, and supplied Kay with information on transport between destinations.
I asked whether the swimming pool at the four-star San Pietro Hotel would be open, and Kay told me it never closed.
She was pleased when the quote worked out at just under £2,200, and said that included a 5 per cent discount from Going Places/Mytravel. A good saleswoman, she added that there were 'only a few places left', and urged me to book quickly. I was in and out of the shop in 25 minutes.
Verdict: Although Kay had little knowledge of Italy, she used the Cresta consultant's expertise to recommend hotels and get all the flight and land travel information I would need. I ended up questioning, however, why I didn't book direct and save myself the visit.
Satisfaction rating: 7/10
The tour operator
I rang Kirker Holidays - and what a delight. After explaining my requirements the consultant, Ian, immediately asked what standard of hotels I wanted, and recommended two in Florence and one in Venice. They were all four-star and in central locations that fitted the bill. His suggested hotel overlooking Lake Garda, the Sirmione, sounded ideal, with indoor and outdoor pools.
The best way to get between the hotels was by train, but we could hire a car near Lake Garda for sightseeing, he said.
Finding out which hotels had available rooms wouldn't be a problem, he said, but the first priority was to hold the flights. After doing a live check on the booking system two British Airways seats were reserved, but Ian reassured me they could be cancelled if I decided not to go ahead with the holiday.
He gave me the flight times and confirmed we could fly into Venice and out of Pisa. 'It's only a one-hour journey from the centre of Florence to Pisa airport,' he said. And he talked me through some suitable hotels in both Florence and Venice, all central, four-star and with character.
A few hours later Ian came back to me with a full itinerary. The 13-night trip cost £3,094, just a little over my budget.
Verdict: A quick, efficient and professional service, which was hard to fault.
Ian had a superb knowledge of Italy, recommended lovely hotels and knew the intricacies of getting to and from each place. Why go to a travel agent when you can get first-class service direct from a specialist?
Satisfaction rating: 10/10
Factfile
Kirker Holidays (020 7231 3333)
Going Places/Mytravel (0870 241 5339)
Personal Travel Advisers (01264 338733)
Other travel agents offering a similar service include Travel Counsellors (01204 536000)